Culture
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
Culture · News article
Waymos have become increasingly visible in California’s biggest cities over the past several years, establishing a presence from San Francisco to San Jose.
The robotaxi service has further expanded to Los Angeles, San Diego and even Sacramento earlier this year, where the vehicles are currently in testing. But the service expansion has also come with controversy and safety concerns.
Earlier this month the California Department of Motor Vehicles temporarily banned Waymos from operating on all state highways until further notice.
A DMV spokesperson told CapRadio the restrictions come after two major incidents. One case saw three Waymos drive into an active construction zone near Burlingame. Another incident involved one of the autonomous vehicles (AVs) attempting to pass a CHP cruise doing traffic calming operations near San Francisco.
The DMV determined that Waymo’s continued highway operations pose an “imminent hazard” to public safety, and required the company to take corrective action and prove its vehicles can respond safely before the ban is lifted.
A Waymo spokesperson told CapRadio safety remains the company’s top priority, and it has paused highway driving nationwide as it works with the DMV and other state officials. Waymo says it will continue to operate on city streets.
Jean Paul Velez is the Principal Transportation Planner for the San Francisco County Transportation Authority, which manages the city’s congestion and traffic networks.
He spoke with Insight Host Vicki Gonzalez about the DMV’s recent restrictions, and the lessons learned from having autonomous vehicles operating on San Francisco’s streets.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Interview highlights
What has stood out to you over the past several years as Waymos and similar vehicles have been on San Francisco’s streets?
[Autonomous vehicles] have been testing in San Francisco for a long time, but it’s more around 2023 when they began their driverless operations [and] we began to observe various safety incidents. We started to see obstructions of first responders and transit vehicles, vehicles entering work zones, and other cases of AVs stopping in the middle of the road for no apparent reason.
At that time we had two providers, Waymo and Cruise. And actually, Cruise then had a series of more concerning safety events that ended in a very severe injury to a pedestrian. That led to them getting suspended and that company shut down the following year. Whereas Waymo we've seen actually evolve and grow significantly in San Francisco; they're a very popular way to get around.
A Waymo car drives up a hill in San Francisco, Thursday, Sept. 4, 2025.AP Photo/Jeff Chiu
There's still safety incidents and again with this freeway restriction, we see that there are things to continue to improve. But generally AVs drive safely, and in normal conditions they behave much like a careful human driver. But there's just new series of events that always cause additional ways of thinking about AV safety, [whether] freeways or the first responder issues that we've seen in San Francisco so often.
You're a local transportation agency. What kind of authority do you have to regulate or even restrict self-driving cars?
At the local level there is no permitting authority. Cities and counties don't decide which companies operate in their jurisdiction. They don't say which neighborhoods, the hours, the number of vehicles — we have no say over any of that.
Both regulators, the CPUC and the DMV, are very open to hearing from cities, local jurisdictions, and so we elevate any issue of concern. But after that, it's in their hands… the actual processing, and any particular action that they may decide to take.
What are some of the regulations that California has put in place for self-driving cars?
The regulations for AVs date back almost a decade now, and they were recently updated. For instance, in this incident with Waymo we see the effect of the new regulations. The DMV, through this new process, has new authorities that allow it to restrict AV operations, as opposed to before where they were only allowed to just suspend, ban or take no action at all. That was an important improvement that we saw in the regulations, that now we see it being leveraged in this case.
Given that there are so many different ways to get around in San Francisco, what share are autonomous vehicles in that transportation ecosystem?
That's another piece of the puzzle that has been hard to explore and analyze in detail, because most of the data that AV providers submit or report to regulators is not made publicly available. So cities actually don't have official information of what is happening in their streets, and how they may be impacted.
We have a general sense — from either some of the available data from public reports or the information that Waymo, for example, submits — that about 2% of the vehicle miles in San Francisco on a daily basis are Waymo miles. But again, the information is rather imperfect precisely because a lot of [it] is getting redacted [or] not made available to the public.
When you first learned of the DMV's ban on Waymos driving on the highway, did that news come as a surprise?
There are a few elements that I would highlight from the incident. We're still learning [because] the news is so fresh. But notably, the news reports kind of showcase very strong language by the DMV, in my opinion. Their statement says that they determined, as you were quoting, that Waymo's driverless operations on freeways pose an imminent hazard to public safety.
I see in that action from the DMV, a clear positive in that, on the one hand, they are actively monitoring and they took immediate action. And then secondly, these new regulations gave them additional powers to actually restrict operations as opposed to being more black and white. But there remain questions. How is the DMV going to actually determine when and how safe Waymo’s going to be to return to freeway operations, particularly with this notion that this is a repeated case?
A Waymo vehicle is displayed at a Google I/O event in Mountain View, Calif., May 19, 2026.AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File
We had learned from the publicly-available information that Waymo had issued a voluntary recall of freeway operations following [a] similar incident on the freeway in May. But the DMV statement actually references a prior restriction by the department. That was very interesting; there was a prior restriction, they have been allowed to come back to the freeway, now they're restricted again. One imagines that maybe the bar is going to be raised. We'll also be interested to see where the federal government steps in because some of the safety performance issues of autonomous vehicles are more in the jurisdiction of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
As you laid out, there’s some information that you don’t have access to. That must make it difficult to get a clear picture of what traffic and the types of vehicles moving through your city actually look like?
Both on the traffic side and on the safety side, it's a challenge to not have access to the wealth of information that regulators receive. That would allow us to actually make our own determinations, not only about the performance of these vehicles to the extent possible, but also take corrective actions and coordinate with them more closely.
On the safety side, we're the ones that are most affected. Cities are seeing things first and we are the ones on the ground every day. We hear from residents, our firefighters, our police department, they're running to these cars. That puts us in a good position to flag problems early and then take corrective actions through a range of different policy measures.
But again, it also goes beyond safety. AVs could change how people get around, and San Francisco — for one — has a transit-first policy. It's our north star for our mobility, and taxpayers invest heavily in supporting that vision. So, we need to make sure that new kinds of transportation support that vision.
Are self-driving cars getting better at adapting to changing road conditions, or do the same issues continue to crop up?
The “better” is an interesting qualification. I think what we can tell are these parallel stories. AVs generally drive safely, and recent studies suggest that they crash less often than human drivers — although again, this lack of access to information does not allow the city to kind of make its own assessment of that issue.
Where they seem to struggle is with situations that they haven't seen before. The emergency scenes, the work zones, or particularly interactions with a first responder. Many of these situations are routine for a careful human driver, like pulling over for an ambulance, reading a pedestrian waving at you, or following a construction worker giving you a hand signal. All of those things are basic for a human, but it seems that it’s hard for an AV. That’s one issue that makes you wonder how AI works in learning and adapting.
A San Francisco Police officer checks on a Waymo vehicle that was stopped in a crosswalk, Wednesday, Nov. 4, 2026, in San Francisco.AP Photo/Jeff Chiu
Then we have this new problem added to that: repetition. It’s one thing for a company to struggle with emergency vehicles or work zones in its early days. It’s another to see them make similar mistakes years later, or when they claim that issues have been fully resolved.
What are the main forces that are shaping policies focused on autonomous vehicles in California and across the country, especially as the industry is growing?
I'm sure that safety is the number one concern for everyone. Of course, there's great potential from an economic growth perspective for this industry at the local San Francisco level, at the state level and nationally. And there’s some balancing between accepting some level of risk that allows for the industry and the technology to continue to mature.
That is some of the challenge of really calibrating that balance; at times, we need to go back and iterate to continue to make it better. Cities, we believe, need to have more of a say in that calibration and be more of a participant of that debate.
Waymos are currently testing on Sacramento’s streets. Do you think self-driving cars are ready to expand to other cities?
I don't know if that's for me exactly to say. I think what we see in San Francisco and throughout California is a growth in demand. The public is speaking with their feet, if you will. They like these services, and they want to see them continue to expand. And we’ve seen our regulators grant them the permits to continue to expand, so we see all of those as signs that yes, that expansion should continue. But again, how we continue to expand is the part that I've been stressing, which is more in partnership with cities.
A Waymo Zeekr drives through downtown Sacramento near J and 5th Streets on Aug. 7, 2026. The company is testing autonomous vehicles in the city before launching public rides.Tony Rodriguez/CapRadio
What lessons do you think newer cities like Sacramento should learn from established cities like San Francisco about handling self-driving cars and robotaxis?
The main lesson is to try to be proactive in this void of tangible policy tools for cities to manage AVs. They still have the softer tools; engaging the provider is going to very actively manifest what you want to see. If you see a problem, collaborate with them to try to see it addressed. There's no authority behind that engagement, but at least there's the proactivity of it all that hopefully helps solve issues or avoid problems in the future.
The second one is to actually leverage the networks of cities that have already gone through some of the growing steps, and maybe have some additional wonky answers.
A lot of people haven’t been on a Waymo, but may live where they are testing. What do you want them to understand about how they operate?
Everyone can form their own opinion, so I think probably take a ride, see how you feel.
Follow us for more stories like this
CapRadio provides a trusted source of news because of you. As a nonprofit organization, donations from people like you sustain the journalism that allows us to discover stories that are important to our audience. If you believe in what we do and support our mission, please donate today.