This report was updated at 2:30pm Nov. 10, with 85% of votes counted statewide.
California voters rejected a first-of-its-kind tax on billionaires.
With nearly 85% of the votes counted, the Secretary of State reported that 52.8% of voters –a 621,465-vote margin – rejected Proposition 40, a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of the state’s roughly 200 billionaires.
The tax would have targeted the billionaires' stocks, bonds, business holdings and other valuable personal property. As the tally progressed through the week after the Nov. 3 election, the margin of victory narrowed by more than 200,000 votes, but not nearly enough to approve the one-time tax.
The defeat of the measure marked a defeat for organized labor and progressives. Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West, the primary union pushing the measure, said it would have generated an estimated $100 billion for healthcare and education to be spent over the next five years.
The nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office estimated the tax would raise “tens of billions of dollars” over several years, well short of the union’s projection, and warned that billionaires leaving the state could cut income tax revenue by less than $1 billion a year.
The union and other supporters argued that billionaires should pay their fair share to support social services programs the Trump administration cut last year.
The results could have been complicated by two competing ballot measures: Propositions 41 and 42. Proponents of those measures designed them to conflict with Prop. 40. If either countermeasure received more votes than Prop. 40, it would have nullified the billionaire tax.
From the outset, Prop. 40 revealed divisions in the Democratic Party and galvanized some of Silicon Valley’s wealthiest executives to spend hundreds of millions to defeat it.
Gov. Gavin Newsom became one of its earliest opponents, attempting through backroom negotiations to keep Prop. 40 off the ballot altogether. San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan also opposed the measure.
Newsom endorsed Prop. 42, a billionaire-backed countermeasure designed to ban all wealth taxes in California and kill Prop. 40. Proposition 42 was approved by a more than 350,000 votes, 52% to 48%. Proposition 41, which would have banned any similar initiative, was rejected by a 55%-to-45% margin.
Newsom, along with a cadre of Democratic allies such as Planned Parenthood of California and the California Teachers Association, argued a one-time tax would not solve the state’s fiscal woes and would drive wealthy residents out of state.
Despite party and labor divisions, the California Democratic Party and California Federation of Labor Unions supported the initiative and opposed its counter measures, arguing the state needs more revenue to shield workers and everyday Californians from the effects of dramatic federal healthcare cuts expected to kick 2 million residents off health insurance.
Billionaire opponents spent heavily
Billionaire opponents and business interests poured $316.7 million into the campaign to stop Prop. 40 — including support for Props. 41 and 42 — telling voters nearly the same message: Wealthy residents who contribute jobs to the economy and income tax to state coffers have already left, and more will follow if the initiative passes. They also made a largely misleading claim that lawmakers could lower the threshold of the wealth tax to include everyday Californians.
Google co-founder Sergey Brin led the opposition, publicly moving out of state and donating $102 million to Building a Better California, a political committee he founded to oppose the tax. The group served as a passthrough for other billionaire donors to oppose Prop. 40.
Prop. 41 would have prohibited the state from collecting taxes that circumvent the state spending limit set in 1979, which Prop. 40 was designed to do.
Prop. 42 will prohibit the state from taxing financial assets of private businesses, pensions and other forms of wealth. It also prohibits retroactive taxes.
The state constitution dictates that when there are multiple competing ballot measures on the same ballot, the one that receives the most votes wins, nullifying its competitors.
Allegations against SEIU leader
Prop. 40 was the brainchild of Dave Regan, president of Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West. He has been mired in scandal in recent months.
Some members of SEIU California, the political umbrella organization representing the healthcare workers union, have accused him of threatening and intimidating women over the years and of attempting to “extort” support for the measure, according to an internal investigation commissioned by SEIU California and SEIU, the union’s national parent organization.
Separately, the California Primary Care Association, which represents clinics and opposes Prop. 44, another ballot measure run by Regan’s union, alleged in a recent lawsuit that the health workers union violated anti-racketeering laws in part by asking clinics to support the billionaire tax in exchange for killing the clinic initiative.
The union and Regan have called these allegations “categorically false” and characterized them as a “smear campaign” designed to derail the billionaire tax.
Prop. 1 Issue $11.25 billion in bonds for multi-family housing, youth housing and veterans’ home loan subsidies 61% Yes 39% No
Prop. 2 Increase budget stabilization account to 20% from 10%. 61% Yes 39% No
Prop. 3 Renew 2012 income tax for education and early childhood programs 61% Yes 39% No
Prop. 4 Allow public funding of political campaigns 49.7% Yes 50.3% No (A margin of less than 70,000 votes.)
Prop. 5 Eliminate successor elections to fill seats left vacant after recall 52% Yes 48% No
Prop. 37 Issue $25 billion in bonds to fund second mortgage homebuyer program 62% Yes 38% No
Prop. 38 Issue $8.4 billion for immunology and immunotherapy research 54% Yes 46% No
Prop. 39 Require government-issue for citizenship proof for Voter ID 39% Yes 61% No
Prop. 40 Levy special one-time 5% tax on billionaires to fund health care programs 47.2% Yes 52.8% No
Prop. 41 Require revenues from new special levy to be spent on low-performing programs. 45.1% Yes 54.9% No
Prop. 42 Prohibit use of new special levy on retirement or savings 52% Yes 48% No
Prop. 43 Require ⅔ public vote for new local tax levies 43% Yes 57% No
Prop. 44 Prohibit from spending less than 90% on mission-related activities 18% Yes 82% No
Prop. 45 Establish guidelines for local governments to solicit public comments on essential projects. 44% Yes 56% No
Kristen Hwang, a reporter with CalMatters, contributed to this report.