Culture
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
Business · News article
For a year that produced a roughly $70 billion apartment company, a wholesale California portfolio exit, and a $2 billion partnership between public and private capital, 2026 has required considerable patience from multifamily investors. Yes, the biggest owners are redrawing their portfolios and operating platforms, but across the rest of the market, getting a single property to trade still requires buyers and sellers to agree on what its income is worth.
For Jim Costello, executive director of research and head of real estate economics at MSCI, the distinction lies beneath the $114.1 billion in third-quarter apartment transactions, up 139% year over year. Nearly $80 billion came from portfolio and entity-level deals, while individual property sales totaled approximately $34 billion, down 12%.
“The individual asset sales, that’s always the bedrock of the market,” Costello says. “It’s not as if the Vivmark deal, even though the headline numbers are so great, it’s not like that happened because everybody’s so excited about the strength of the sector.”
The August combination of AvalonBay Communities and Equity Residential into Vivmark Residential brought together more than 184,000 apartments, creating a platform whose ambitions span centralized operations, technology investment, development, and a lower cost of capital. Costello sees the pursuit of management efficiencies as a response to pressures that are also keeping buyers and sellers apart at the property level.
“There’s challenges in the market with prices falling, cap rates rising, revenue under pressure, and even with rising vacancy rates,” he says. “The headline numbers for the year are big, but they’re also a bit of a head fake.”
Camden’s $1.625 billion sale of 11 Southern California communities to a BlackRock-managed vehicle and UDR’s announced $2 billion Apollo partnership further illustrate the scale of institutional repositioning. The Camden sale transferred 3,620 apartments, with JLL arranging $566.6 million in agency financing across seven properties. Under UDR’s proposed arrangement, Apollo would invest $1.34 billion for roughly two-thirds of a 7,059-apartment portfolio at an implied 6% cap rate, while UDR would retain management and a one-third interest, freeing capital for higher-growth investments and debt reduction.
For established apartment owners pursuing individual acquisitions, the opportunities have required considerably more sorting. At Atlanta-based Cortland, director of investments Kyle Bateh describes a year spent working through a broad pipeline of marketed properties and opportunities sourced through lenders, sponsors, and other relationships.
“The balance of 2026 has really been about scouring the market for individual opportunities that just work,” Bateh says. “We certainly have markets that we like, and that we’re invested in, and that we continue to like. But it’s kind of been one of those markets where it’s less about, ‘Hey, I need to go buy more Carolinas or more Texas.’ It’s really been opportunity driven.”
That search has unfolded against an improving operating picture that briefly looked capable of supporting more transactions. Early in the year, Bateh says, five-year fixed-rate agency financing with a rate buydown could land in the high 4% to low 5% range, alongside acquisition cap rates around 5%.
“So you effectively had neutral to positive leverage for the first time in a while,” he says. “The spring leasing season was pretty good, and fundamentals were starting to improve. We had more and more markets every week, every month, that were actually showing positive blended lease trade-outs.”
Cortland’s portfolio occupancy improved almost 300 basis points through spring and summer, but by fall comparable debt was pricing in the low 6% range, Bateh says, putting fresh upward pressure on acquisition yields.
“We’re judging this against the backdrop of a market that’s becoming more constructive from a fundamental standpoint, but at the same time sort of deteriorating from a capital market standpoint,” he says.
Underwriting the Recovery
MSCI’s third-quarter data puts the quality-adjusted apartment cap rate at 5.9%, up 20 basis points year over year, with prices down 4.6%. Its separate monthly financing series shows how much the relationship between yields and borrowing costs has changed: Apartment cap rates were approximately 4.6% against average seven- and 10-year fixed mortgage rates of 4.3% in June 2022. By August, both measures were around 5.7%.
For Bateh, the resulting discipline incumbent to both buyers and sellers is overdue after the short holds, aggressive rent assumptions, and floating-rate leverage that characterized the pandemic-era buying cycle.
“Real estate is based on long-term ownership. It is based on a hedge against inflation. It should be cash flow oriented, and if you make some money on the appreciation, great,” he says. “You can’t buy a three cap and hope for 6% rent growth to get your target stable yield.”
At Bainbridge Cos., that recalibration has meant holding off on acquisitions while preparing for opportunities that president Brian Doppelt expects to become more attractive as the market adjusts. The firm had made no new purchases across 2026 when he spoke with Multifamily Executive in late October.
“We’ve been highly focused on operating fundamentals, and ensuring that our current portfolio is occupied as well as it can be,” Doppelt says. “Taking a hard look at expenses, and ensuring strong lease-ups across the lease-up portion of the portfolio.”
Even with a development business approaching $4 billion in historical activity, Doppelt nonetheless expects buying existing properties to take greater precedence over the next several years for Bainbridge.
“We’re still developers, but I think there’s probably more of an opportunity on a risk-adjusted basis to acquire assets,” Doppelt says. “We’re certainly on the hunt for portfolios. We’re looking at a couple at the moment, and the question, just again, is: Where are the assets? How old are they? What’s the pricing?”
Bainbridge’s willingness to wait reflects confidence that the supply cycle will eventually reward that patience, particularly as concessions recede.
“We anticipate those concessions to burn off, and they are starting to in various markets,” Doppelt says. “When you combine those supply-demand dynamics, with demand being quite strong, and absorption being certainly better than expected given all the supply, we’re excited to see the rent growth that will hopefully result from the market hitting equilibrium, and then changing direction.”
For acquisitions, the question is how much of that anticipated improvement a seller already expects buyers to pay for.
Those same questions have led Carmel Partners to entrench deeper into coastal gateway markets, where chief investment officer Bryan Crane says the firm’s data science platform identified improving demand before broader investor sentiment caught up. Downtown Boston offered a combination of returning office workers and limited supply, for example, and in the Bay Area, the firm saw employment and investment signals that justified buying through the pessimism.
“We were investing in San Francisco and the Bay Area when other people thought the Bay Area was gonna fall off the edge of the earth,” Crane says. “We saw something different happening in the data, and it was telling us that people were returning to the office. It was telling us this artificial intelligence (AI) investment, and this AI growth in the Bay Area, was real.”
Carmel was approximately 60% to 65% invested in its latest fund when Crane spoke with MFE, with the cost and difficulty of building competing properties reinforcing its conviction in those markets.
“That combination of factors, particularly in the coastal markets, where land is expensive, interest rates are high, construction costs are high, is really prohibitive for many people to start new-construction projects,” he says. “We’re looking for areas where supply is limited and where demand is really strong, and the demand drivers are very strong.”
The Limits of Patience
The prospect of capturing that rent growth also gives existing owners a reason to wait. Carmel sold a longtime San Francisco holding in 2026 while continuing to buy in the market, although Crane says the operating outlook supports retaining many of its investments.
“What we’re seeing right now, based on the fundamentals on the ground, is that there’s very strong rent growth that’s been happening and, in many cases, is still happening and forthcoming,” he says. “For most of our assets in these very strong markets, it actually benefits them to hold.”
For Cortland, buying and holding decisions turn on many of the same indicators: concessions burning off, lease trade-outs before and after those concessions, and the remaining supply pipeline. Getting a seller to participate, however, can depend on circumstances well beyond the leasing office.
“It really takes a motivated and realistic seller,” Bateh says. “That could be for a variety of reasons: liquidity needs, fatigue, fund life, or the maturity of a loan that can’t be refinanced.”
Attractive assumable fixed-rate debt can help a transaction along, he adds, providing certainty for both parties when new financing is subject to market swings. But the availability of refinancing has also given owners an alternative to accepting a buyer’s price, prolonging the wait for acquisition teams ready to deploy capital.
“A lot of would-be sellers were able to refinance and kick the can, and I just don’t think over the next six months, 12 months, that that’s gonna happen at the clip it did over the last six or 12 months,” Bateh says. “And so, therefore, there’s going to be a lot more activity at the market.”
That is where the outlook for 2027 brings buyers with otherwise different strategies into agreement. Doppelt expects pressure from lenders to play a larger role in generating transactions than sellers voluntarily revising their expectations.
“I don’t think sellers are gonna wake up one day and just decide to sell for less or take a loss,” he says. “I think lenders are likely going to push them in that direction.”
Crane sees a similar limit approaching for borrowers whose equity has been depleted while lenders grant additional time. Carmel has already found one such opportunity for its current fund.
“It’s been easier for lenders, quite frankly, to give their borrowers more time than to foreclose on those assets and either bring in a new operator to manage them or to sell them off,” Crane says. “These capital stacks, in a sense, are broken, because the equity is either out of the money or pretty close to being out of the money. And the equity is starting to run out of time. The lenders simply can’t extend forever.”
Costello expects recovering rents to help investor confidence if economic growth continues supporting demand as supply is absorbed. But the pricing reset remains unfinished, and the lending relationships that have allowed owners to work through difficulties distinguish this market from the forced selling of the Global Financial Crisis.
“You’d still have to clear through a lot of the embedded price expectations for assets that people currently hold,” he says. “And that’s not a fast thing to happen.”
For buyers anticipating the next opening, that leaves the work of underwriting an individual property, its market and its financing as consequential as ever, even as institutional ownership changes around them.
“Everybody looks at this market and says, OK, there’s some distress here, there’s some repricing. How did people make money in the last downturn?” Costello says, explaining a look-back strategy common to cyclical markets. “They’ll get it wrong, because the forces today are different from the ones we saw in the financial crisis.”